







|
| CASE
STUDY - Telephone House |
|
| Shrewsbury
with Atcham Borough Council
|
| Project: |
Telephone
House, Shrewsbury |
| Client: |
Shrewsbury & Atcham
Borough Council, The Guildhall, Dogpole, Shrewsbury, Shropshire,
SY1 1ER |
| Planning
Supervisor: |
John
Pidgeon Partnership, Suite 5, Noram Suite, Victoria Road, Shifnal,
Shropshire, TF11 8AG |
| Project
Manager: |
Mr.
John Pidgeon, John Pidgeon Partnership |
| Principal
Contractor: |
Walter
Forshaw Ltd, 7 King Street, Westhoughton, Bolton, BL5 3AY |
| WFL
Engineer: |
The
Healy Brown Partnership, Brunel House, 63 Dale Street, Milnrow,
Rochdale, OL16 3NJ |
| Contract
Description: |
Demolition
and site clearance of a 9 storey office block known as Telephone
House. Removal of all identified hazardous materials, ground
floor slab and site tidy on completion. |
| Value: |
£300,000 |
Timescale: |
22
weeks – July 2002 to December 2002 |
|
|
|
|
|
Contract
Background:
In
order to effect the demolition safely and economically, Shrewsbury & ABC
initiated a rigid pre-qualification and subsequent tendering regime, requiring
substantial pre-qualification submissions and, for successful pre-qualified contractors,
an exhaustive tender submission with detailed method statements to be submitted
by all tenderers.
Following comparison of tenders, Shrewsbury & ABC invoked an evaluation scoring
system, which took into account all aspects of the submission from price, safety,
method statements, quality of submission etc. before finally appointing Walter
Forshaw to carry out the demolition despite not being the lowest tender.
Building Construction:
The contract was to demolish a ten-storey office building within the heart of
the historical City of Shrewsbury; the structure being closely surrounded on
all 4 sides. Available room around the site ranged from 8m to 14m to the nearest
structure. Surrounding land use included a major city centre road, the central
bus station, an office building, a multi-storey car park and shopping centre,
between which the site had to be accessed.
The building was constructed of an ‘Omnia’ pre-cast concrete floor
system spanning from central reinforced concrete columns and beams which acted
longitudinally into the reinforced concrete shear walls situated at either end
of the building and centrally within the staircase and lift shaft core. The floors
spanned from the central column and beam arrangement to pre-cast concrete wall
panels.
The unusual nature of this building construction had lead to considerable structural
deterioration during its life span and had been historically linked to excessive
sway during high winds. As a result, it was decided that demolition rather than
refurbishment was the most suitable option.
Demolition
Method:
Walter Forshaw evaluated all the options and decided that it would be necessary
to fully scaffold the building and encapsulate the structure with Mona flex sheeting.
The building was cleared of a small quantity of asbestos and soft stripped of
the internal fixtures and fittings during scaffold erection.
The lift shafts were cleared of the cars and guides to enable the shaft to be
used as a debris chute during the soft strip and dismantling phase of the works.
Prior to structural dismantling, the floors were back-propped in accordance with
our engineer’s design to withstand the loads imposed by plant, equipment
and debris, and the external wall panels were propped using push-pull props to
maintain their structural integrity during the dismantling operation.
The sequence of dismantling involved removing the lift houses and plant rooms,
followed by the floor-by-floor deconstruction of the top 5 floors, prior to long
reach demolition of the remaining structure.
During the initial stages of the dismantling operation, it became apparent that
due to the poor construction, pre-planned sequences had to be altered, as the
inherent strength within the structure did not materialise as the design criteria
indicated.
Despite the challenges the early phases posed, the contract was completed on
time and to budget and an unsolicited testimony received from the Planning Supervisor
upon completion.
Reference
Details:
Please contact WFL for reference contact details.
See attached letter from John Pidgeon Partnership. |
|
|