| Project: |
Former
A1 Bridges, Yorkshire |
| Client: |
RMG
(Darrington) Ltd |
| Planning
Supervisor: |
Kellogg,
Brown & Root Ltd, Hill Park Court, Springfield Drive, Letherhead,
Surrey, KT22 7NL |
| Consulting
Engineer: |
Peter
Lindsell & Associates, Purlins, 159 Woodlands Road, Woodlands,
Southampton, Hampshire, SO40 7GL |
| Explosives
Engineer: |
PDC
Ltd, 11 Blackmoor Crescent, Sheffield, South Yorkshire, S8 8LA |
| Principal
Contractor: |
RMG
(A1) Construction, Site Office, Lumby, South Milford, LS25 5LD |
| Contract
Description: |
The
contract involved the demolition of 9 redundant bridges on the
former A1 in Yorkshire. |
| Value: |
£600,000 |
Timescale: |
56
weeks – March 2005 to April 2006 |
|
Building
Construction:
The demolition nine redundant bridges on the former A1 in Yorkshire
posed many intriguing problems for the WFL design team due to
there being many different types of bridge involved - road over
motorway, footbridge over road, road over river and road over
railway – requiring various demolition techniques. These
techniques ranged from traditional demolition by mechanical excavator
to the explosive demolition of an accommodation bridge over the
M62 during a 15-hour overnight motorway possession.
Planning:
All the bridges required thorough planning, including design data, technical
appraisal forms and methods of demolition, which needed to be certificated by
a Category III checker and the client prior to being passed offt.
Walshford Bridge
The Walshford Bridge, spanning the river Nidd, required close liaison with the
Environment Agency. After several site meetings, we concluded that the best method
for demolition was to remove as much of the road deck as possible before breaking
out any remaining structure, including the beams, allowing them to drop in to
the river below. The EA installed two inflatable rubber bunds and a submerged
hessian net downstream of the bridge to catch small debris and oil. Upon conclusion,
the river was dredged of any demolition material.
Holmfield Lane Accommodation Bridge
This demolition of Holmfield Lane bridge was complicated by the fact that it
spanned the busy M62 motorway and could therefore only be demolished during a
15-hour overnight motorway possession.
Early on in the planning process we opted for demolition using controlled explosives
to give us maximum time to remove the bridge material and return the motorway
to normal use.
In the weeks leading up to the possession, the bridge was prepared for explosive
demolition by removing the road deck and drilling the surface and bridge piers
to accept the charges under a series of overnight lane closures over the live
motorway.
On the night of the possession, once the motorway had been closed, protective
layers consisting of geotextile, plywood sheets, sand and tyres were laid down
under the bridge to protect the motorway from the falling bridge material. Once
all the protective material was in place and the explosives were charged, the
bridge was detonated.
The rest of the night was spent removing the bridge material to
the side of the motorway where it was processed later.
The material was cleared and the motorway was inspected and handed
back on time early on the Sunday morning.
Micklefield Railway Bridge
The Micklefield Railway Bridge was the most complex of all the bridges,
requiring meticulous planning and an innovative solution. It presented
us with our biggest challenge of 2005, if not the last 10 years!
Background:
The bridge formerly carried the A1 dual carriageway over a busy mainline railway
but the new A1(M), 20 metres to the east, rendered this bridge redundant. Due
to the high frequency of trains along the Trans-Pennine line, the only period
Network Rail would allow the railway to be closed for a reasonable length of
time was over Christmas Day and Boxing Day, totalling a 53 hour possession.
Planning:
Our design team considered several methods for the demolition of Micklefield
Railway Bridge, taking into account the critical timescale involved; potential
damage to the track and related penalties; the particular construction detail
within the bridge structure; the unpredictable nature of the weather over the
Christmas period.
The suggested methods included mechanical demolition using excavators fitted
with combination shears; cutting and lifting sections of the bridge with a crane;
using controlled explosives. The mechanical demolition method was eliminated
due to the complex nature of the post-tensioning in the concrete. The lifting
method was eliminated due to the size and weight of pieces that would have to
be lifted, the awkwardness of the site and the changeable nature of the wind
in winter. After careful consideration, our most favourable method was to use
controlled explosives.
Explosive Demolition using Water Bags:
The construction of the bridge and the complex post-tensioning within the beams
prevented traditional explosive drilling. Our design team, including our explosives
engineer and structural engineer, a leading expert in concrete bridge construction
(and demolition!), concluded that the best way would be to employ a little known
and rarely used technique involving explosives submerged in water bags within
the bridge structure.
The basic idea is that the water bag fills the expanse between beams and, when
the explosives are detonated inside the bag, the force is transmitted through
the water equally in all directions, not only destroying the concrete within
the bridge, but also turning the concrete to a gravel, helping to reduce the
time taken to clear the bridge after detonation. The method had not been used
in anger on any bridge before that we were aware of, so we performed several
test blasts on an intact section of a bridge we had demolished previously, to
ascertain the ideal amount of explosives to use, the correct quantity of water
and the type of water bag required. The test blasts went well and, once we were
confident of our method, we presented our proposals to our client and Network
Rail.
Protection:
The protection required beneath the bridge would need to be strong enough to
take the weight of the bridge material, estimated at 1000 tonnes. The track protection
was further complicated by three factors:
• the bridge spanned a section of the railway containing points which merged
four tracks in to two directly beneath the bridge, so there was additional switchgear
to protect.
• Network Rail would not allow any sandbags to be placed directly on either the
tracks or on the sleepers.
• a dilapidated trough, containing fibre optic cables, ran adjacent to one abutment
directly under the bridge and could not bear the weight of any protection materials.
Several ideas were suggested by the design team, before finally settling on using
a combination of geotextile, sandbags, timber matting, plywood sheeting and tyres.
We arranged several night-time “between-trains” possessions to take
detailed measurements of the track layout, which allowed us to design our track
protection system.
Preparation:
In the weeks leading up to Christmas, the bridge was prepared for demolition,
by removing the road deck from the bridge and excavating 20,000 tonnes of fill
material from behind the abutments of the bridge. Holes were drilled on the deck,
large enough to accept the water bags. The bags were placed in these holes, filled
with water and charged with explosives. The abutments were also drilled and primed
with explosives. Protective matting was then draped over the bridge to contain
any materials thrown up in the blast.
Regular meetings were held in the weeks prior to Christmas with the local residents,
Micklefield Parish Council and the local police, to discuss arrangements for
the blowdown. Letter drops and door-to-door liaison was also carried out with
the residents in the neighbouring properties to keep them abreast of the latest
developments.
Blowdown:
Late on Christmas Eve, our protection team arrived on site and as soon as the
railway was handed over to us - 02:00 on Christmas Day morning – commenced
placing the protection down on the track. At 11:30 the bridge was ready for the
blowdown. We arranged a rolling road block with the local police on the neighbouring
A1(M), giving us a three minute detonation window, and the bridge was detonated
just before noon. Close inspection of the bridge after the explosion, revealed
that the water bag method had worked perfectly, turning much of the bridge deck
into gravel.
Clean Up:
Our team of excavators proceeded to work away at the broken bridge structure
and, by 01:00 on Boxing Day morning, the track was clear. At first light, the
railway inspectors surveyed the track and checked all signalling & points
equipment. They were extremely impressed with the condition of all track & equipment
and passed the railway off as fit for trains to run, a full 24 hours ahead of
schedule, and the operation was deemed a success.
Reference
Details:
Please contact WFL for reference contact details.
See attached letter from Micklefield Parish Council.
|